This is the most backwards thing you’ll ever see. It also gives more confidence of the equity surviving even should they be forced to file.
But a bankruptcy filing isn’t imminent for the mall giant, according to people familiar with the matter, and General Growth’s (GGP) ability to remain out of bankruptcy shows the unusual dynamic between lenders and distressed companies in the recession-ravaged commercial-real-estate market.
Bondholders have refrained from forcing mall owner General Growth Properties into bankruptcy court, despite lack of a deal on a debt extension.
Under normal circumstances a company with as much past-due debt as General Growth would have been forced into Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection by now. Creditors so far have been willing to let deadlines pass because they believe there is little to be gained and much to be lost through a bankruptcy. General Growth’s mall operations are stable and many bondholders hope for a greater recovery outside of bankruptcy court.
“This is really rare,” said Kevin Starke, an analyst at CRT Capital Group LLC, a research company that tracks distressed securities. “It is corporate-bond limbo like I’ve never seen before.”
This piggybacks on the thesis laid out here recently that lenders want to avoid a Chapter 11 here at almost all costs.
It continues:
Many creditors say that General Growth’s management is doing a good job running the company. Its 200 U.S. malls, a portfolio second in size only to Simon Property Group Inc., generate enough cash to cover interest on the debt. But its properties are overleveraged and it lacks the borrowing capacity to retire those debts as their principal comes due.
“There’s no question that General Growth is a liquidity issue,” said Jeff Spector, an analyst with UBS AG. “The properties, for the most part, aren’t broken.”
General Growth, based in Chicago, isn’t the only real-estate borrower that is getting a reprieve from its lenders these days. Hundreds of property owners have had loans come due without a repayment made in recent months. But most lenders have agreed to extend loan terms, hoping that the credit market will improve.
For those who did not see it previously, here is the legal basis should it go into bankruptcy for the equity staying in tact. The point that cannot be forgotten here is the company is technically solvent and that alone separates this Chapter 11, should it occur, from 99% of all other Chapter 11’s when the companies entering them are insolvent.
It continues:
A person familiar with the bondholder talks said that, while some creditors are angry, none appears ready to insist on an involuntary bankruptcy petition yet. It is possible that bondholders didn’t go along with the consent solicitation primarily because they feared that making such a pledge would reduce the value of their bonds.
General Growth has told lenders that they’ll have more influence over the outcome if it restructures outside of bankruptcy court, according to people familiar with the talks. A bankruptcy filing could force the company to liquidate its assets for less than the whole company would be worth if it remained a single entity for the long term, these people said.
Another deterrent to an involuntary petition is that bankruptcy wouldn’t bring immediate payment of General Growth’s debts. “It’s such a large company that the bankruptcy would definitely last at least a couple of years,” said Heidi Sorvino, a lawyer leading the bankruptcy practice of law firm Smith, Gambrell & Russell LLP.
The timeframe could be shorter if General Growth did a prepackaged bankruptcy in which the creditors agree to terms prior to the company entering bankruptcy, Ms. Sorvino added. But wrangling so many creditors without the threat of a judge making and enforcing decisions is “almost impossible,” she said.
This is the classic “everyone wins” or “everyone loses”scenario. Banks facing liquidity issues cannot have billions tied up in a Chapter 11 proceeding for years. The viability of common equity, while in my opinion is safe in an 11, can never be assured once the courts get involved. By restructuring out of court and now, everyone wins…
Boilerplate ending for this investment:
Now as usual, a warning. I know people have been following into this investment. If you do, you must be prepared to lose all of it. There is no guarantee of the above outcome. Buying this stock now is essentially buying a call option on the company’s survival. It is hits, you win big, very big. If not, what you invested is worth nothing. I believe the above scenario plays out, I am also not going to be broke should it not.
Disclosure (“none” means no position):Long GGP